In any field, the one that improves the fastest wins. An example from economics comes to mind: a country like France has been rich for centuries, but their economy hasn't been growing much lately. Places like Ireland, Singapore, and Hong Kong, on the other hand, were relatively poor just a few decades ago but have been growing fast since. The latter countries have been able to pass out France in prosperity in just that short time (those interested in economics may want to check out
1 and
2).
Since 2006 I've been trying to improve the quality of poker on TV through the
reviews and
editorials on this site. I've been disappointed to see very little change, however. Consequently, I was thrilled last week to hear that
High Stakes Poker would be showing all the hole cards next season. Not showing all the hole cards was one of my criticisms of the show (though
I have plenty of other criticisms and I hope they make other improvements as well). The real significance of the announcement is that it shows that GSN/Poker PROductions are able to change and improve, which makes anything possible.
ESPN, on the other hand, seems content with producing the same wretched broadcasts of the most important event in poker year after year,
despite my best efforts (and are now the last one, among the big five US poker shows, that don't show all the hole cards).
World Poker Tour Enterprises has done slightly better than that. They've
been criticized for being stagnant, but they did start altering the blind structure less for TV. Once upon a time they even tried to do something groundbreaking: the Professional Poker Tour was an attempt at the PGA-style organization that some people think is the holy grail of televised poker. It didn't survive beyond one season, but at least it was a valiant effort.
The WPT has now
partnered with Fox Sports Net, which has a history of innovative poker programming: they've run various live broadcasts as well as Poker Dome, which won the 2007 Special Award For Innovation
Poky. Unfortunately, their innovations haven't become widespread yet.
I don't think any poker producer or broadcaster is the equivalent of Hong Kong or Singapore in economics yet, but Poker PROductions has made some of the most successful innovations in US TV poker: High Stakes Poker was the first cash game to air in this country; Poker After Dark showed most of the hands and recently added some cash game weeks; and now it looks like we'll see an improved version of High Stakes Poker.
The ability to change and improve is the key to success in any field. It's easier to improve a TV poker show than a fictional show, so there really isn't any excuse for the slow rate of change. Fiction requires talented writers, but poker TV shows can be improved just by making the technical changes talked about in our
reviews and
editorials (as well as poker forums all over the net). It's time for TV executives and poker producers to commit to making some simple changes for the better in their next broadcasts.